Most people check your Google reviews before they call you, book you or walk through your door. More and more of them now skip any business rated below 4.5 stars. This guide explains why that number matters, how many reviews it takes to get there, and how to ask for reviews the right way.
In February, BrightLocal published its yearly survey of how people use reviews. It found that 31% of people will only use a business rated 4.5 stars or higher. A year earlier it was 17%. The share who want at least four stars went from 55% to 68%. It’s a US survey of just over a thousand people, so don’t read too much into the exact figures. But the trend is clear. If you sit on 4.3 stars, nearly a third of people searching may pass you by.
The good news is that this is simple maths, and you can fix it.
How many reviews it takes to reach 4.5 stars
Google shows your rating to one decimal place. As far as anyone can tell, it’s a normal average, rounded up or down.
Take a local barber with 40 reviews and a 4.3 rating. Most of the reviews are five stars, but three old one-star reviews from 2022 drag the average down. That’s 172 stars in total. To show 4.5, the average needs to reach 4.45. If every new review is five stars:
- After 10 more: 222 stars over 50 reviews, an average of 4.44. Google still shows 4.4.
- After 12 more: 232 stars over 52 reviews, an average of 4.46. Google shows 4.5.
So the barber needs twelve new five-star reviews. For a busy business that asks every customer, that’s about a month. If you have 200 reviews at 4.3, you’d need about 55, which is why it pays to sort this out early.
The same survey had two more useful findings. 47% of people won’t use a business with fewer than 20 reviews. And 74% look at reviews from the last three months, while 32% want to see one from the last two weeks. So the number of reviews and how recent they are matter as much as the star rating. A 4.8 from 15 reviews, the newest from 2024, will often lose to a 4.6 from 60 reviews with three from last week.
Why recent reviews count for more
Google’s own help pages say the number of reviews you have and your review score both play a part in how you rank in local results. And as the survey shows, customers look hard at how recent your reviews are. A steady flow of new reviews shows people, and Google, that you’re busy and still doing good work.
A few reviews every week beats a big batch once a year. That comes down to how you ask.
How to ask for reviews so people leave them
BrightLocal found that 28% of people now always leave a review when asked, up from 16% a year earlier. Customers are happy to help. Most businesses just don’t ask, or ask at the wrong time.
- Ask on the day. The haircut looks great or the boiler’s fixed. That’s the moment, not a week later in an email.
- Make it one tap. Copy your review link from your Google Business Profile and save it as a text message on your phone. For example: “Thanks for today, Sarah. If you’ve got 30 seconds, a quick Google review really helps a small business like ours: [link].”
- Ask for a bit of detail. Try “It helps other people if you say what we did and roughly where you are.” You’ll get “fitted a new combi in Purley, tidy and on time” instead of “great service”. Google and AI tools read that detail too.
- Ask everyone, not just your happiest customers. Thirty five-star reviews in one week and nothing after looks suspicious, to customers and to Google.
What the law now says about reviews
Since April 2025, the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act has made some review habits illegal in the UK. Guidance from the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) covers three things small businesses often do without knowing the rules:
- Rewards for reviews. “Leave us a review and get £10 off” counts as a hidden paid review unless it’s clearly declared. Google doesn’t allow rewards for reviews either, so it’s best not to offer them at all.
- Only sending happy customers to Google. A page that says “Happy? Review us on Google. Unhappy? Email us instead” is called review gating. Google doesn’t allow it, and the CMA treats hiding bad reviews as misleading.
- Fake reviews, or reviews from friends and family. The CMA can fine a business up to 10% of its global turnover. In March 2026 it opened five investigations into reviews, including one into a food business accused of offering discounts for five-star reviews without saying so.
Google is cracking down too. It says it blocked or removed over 292 million rule-breaking reviews in 2025 and took down 13 million fake business profiles. It can also pause new reviews on a profile when it spots a sudden spike. So bought reviews don’t just risk a fine. They can freeze your profile just when you need it.
What to do about old bad reviews
Back to the barber and those three one-star reviews from 2022. Google won’t remove a review just because it’s old. But there are three things you can do.
- Reply now, briefly and kindly. For example: “Sorry this happened. Our front desk has completely changed since 2022, and I’d welcome the chance to put it right.” Hundreds of people will read that reply when deciding whether to trust you. BrightLocal found 89% of people expect a business to reply, and 50% are put off by copy-and-paste replies, so write each one yourself.
- Report reviews that break Google’s rules. You can flag reviews from people who were never customers, or that are about a different business. Be honest with yourself about which ones really qualify.
- Outweigh them with new, genuine reviews. That’s the plan above.
Show your best reviews on your website
Since late September 2026, Google Maps has been asking many people to sign in before they can see or sort a business’s full list of reviews. Plenty of people won’t bother. So put your best reviews on your own website, where anyone can read them. Pick five that are most useful and put each one on the page it relates to, with the customer’s first name, the month and what you did for them. Google and AI tools read your website too, so it helps there as well.
Every Ubie pay monthly website can show your reviews on the pages that matter. Start with the saved text message today. Twelve five-star reviews from now, the barber’s problem is solved, and yours can be too.



